by

June 28, 2022

 

Why am I me?


Ethics of Stanford Prison Experiment

The Stanford Prison Experiment was cruel and inhumane but led to great psychological change and discovery. The study was created in order to understand the effects of norms, labels, and societal expectations in a simulated prison environment. Psychologists wanted to figure out why guards had brutal attitudes toward prisoners, being whether this was part of their personality, or if it was due to the prison environment. 

The experiment was advertised in the newspaper. It took random volunteers and split them into prisoners or guards by a coin flip. The psychologists urged the guards to do whatever was necessary to keep the prisoners under command. Prisoners had extreme breakdowns and the guards used excessive violence. The prisoners believed that this experiment was reality and that they were trapped. Zimbardo, the head of this experiment stated,  “At this point, it became clear that we had to end the study. We had created an overwhelmingly powerful situation – a situation in which prisoners were withdrawing and behaving in pathological ways, and in which some of the guards were behaving sadistically.” The experiment that was supposed to last 14 days was stopped after 6 for concerns of abuse.  

This experiment led to a change in ethical guidelines given by the American Psychological Association. Guidelines like extensive debriefing, informed consent, right to withdraw, and protection from psychological and physical harm were put into place. This study is heavily criticized and brought an ethical change in studies going forward. Banks in a research article states, “The study has received many ethical criticisms, including lack of fully informed consent by participants as Zimbardo himself did not know what would happen in the experiment (it was unpredictable),” in defense of the study. 

The Stanford Experiment was the first of its kind and was innovative. The results of the study showed that people will conform to stereotypical roles such as aggressive guards, even if they wouldn’t usually behave in this way. Some people may argue that the experiment was good-natured and that the participants in it spiraled, but I believe that the experiment was made unethically and forced participants to behave violently. 


The twin

Ivy, the protagonist in The Twin, has a few traits that influence her relationships with others.

One, she is Friendly. Two, she is King.  Three, she is thoughtful.

These traits influence her relationships with others. “‘But you’re not failing’, I tell her ‘Take the pressure off. Trust me, you’ll be surprised what that does for you.’” Ivy is nice and supportive to her friends but her sister changes that. Iris, Ivy’s twin sister comes into play here when she convinces Ivy’s best friend that they’re not good at swimming to make them resent Ivy and get them to turn on Ivy. 

Later, on page 286, an old friend of Iris named Kat interacts with Ivy , basically telling her how crazy Ivy is. “‘You need to be careful with this. Believe me, you can’t get ahead of her. She’s sick but she’s also far more conniving than you could ever imagine. Ivy’s response here deepens a reader’s sense of her ambition, and sparks a feeling of fear and curiosity.

https://www.youthvoices.live/tag/psychology-2/