This week, after reading over this New York Times article, I learned more about how the motion to reduce Bears Ears National Monument, among other protected lands, first began. Back in mid-2017, former Interior Secretary Ryan Zinke proposed such legislation to former President Donald Trump. Zinke has stated how the monument was “not the best use of the land,” He as also recommended Trump to not only reduce the land, but turn some of the land within it to be made into national recreation areas or conservation areas, which have lower levels of federal protection.
From this move by Zinke, there was also questioning of the legality of a President reducing previously protected land. By the 1906 Antiquities Act, signed into being by President Theodore Roosevelt, presidents have the power to designate land to be federally protected. Since then, presidents have certainly altered or changed around the borders of existing parks, monuments and areas, but have never reduced it, and certainly not to the extent Trump did. Because of this, many have sued the government over this move, stating that it goes against the Antiquities Act and the separation of powers.
Turkewitz, Julie, and Coral Davenport. “Interior Secretary Recommends Shrinking Borders of Bears Ears Monument.” The New York Times, 12 June 2017, https://www.nytimes.com/2017/06/12/us/interior-secretary-public-lands-utah-bears-ears.html.